Thursday, September 7, 2017

Preparedness of library professionals for the new information environment:

Preparedness of library professionals for the new information environment: A Namibian situation
Paper Presented at the Information Profession in Namibia conference, at UNAM main Campus on 31 August 2017
About the Author
Esther N. Tobias is a Senior Librarian at Ohangwena Regional Study and Resources Centre.  Esther has 6 years of experience working in academic, school and public libraries. She holds a Bachelor of Arts (BA) in Library and Information Science (honours) from University of Namibia and currently pursuing her Masters of Science Degree In library and Information Science at the National University of Science and Technology in Zimbabwe.  Her contacts are: Cell: +264813184557;              E-mail: etobias6@gmail.com
Abstract
Traditionally, libraries used to hold physical resources only. Those who worked in libraries needed skills on how to find hard copies of books, articles and journals. However, this situation has changed, as most of the resources now exist in electronic formats. This new development has not only resulted in information overload, but it requires librarians to have new ways of searching information sources and the ability to evaluate the validity and authenticity of these information sources. Information overload is receiving too much information (Larson & Kulchitsky, 2007). The aim of this paper was to identify skills librarians learnt at work and not during their studies at the Universities, what skills if any they lack when assisting users and how they how they help users who are experiencing information overload. Fifty (50) questionnaires were e-mailed to librarians in Namibia to gather information on their preparedness to handle the new information era.  Findings were that most LIS professionals in Namibia lack skills in information retrieval, information literacy, customer care.  The paper concluded that librarians in Namibia are not sufficiently prepared for the new working environment.




Introduction
Universities strive to sufficiently train and prepare their students to excel in the work environment. Edonkumoh, Nwachukwu & Emmanuel (2015) stated that with the changing needs of employers and the increase of courses associated with librarianship, several alterations have taken place in this field.  These alterations brought conflict of interest whereby employers want to recruit librarians who can perform their tasks effectively.  However, universities are giving theory leaving the practical to employers (Edonkumoh, Nwachukwu & Emmanuel (2015).  It is for this reason that universities should have flexible curriculum to allow amendments which can sufficiently address the development of skills and work readiness by new graduates.   Universities should focus on preparing students to solve a range of unforeseen or unknown problems by reinforcing new ways of thinking and acquiring new kinds of knowledge (Nagarajan & Edwards, 2015).
Traditional librarianship is concerned with functions such as collection development, cataloguing and classification, circulation, preservation, conservation and archiving and these are all done manually.  However in the digital era, some of these functions have become redundant while others have now been computerised (Rowland, 1998).  ICT is now playing a major role in the life of librarians. It requires the librarian to possess skills and be familiar with the new advanced functions of technology.  Information is produced and presented in different types of format such as print, online, DVDs, e-resources, electronic databases and electronic journals etc.  Librarians are required to have the necessary skills to access and retrieve information from all these different types of information source formats.  They have the responsibility to educate the users on the careful use of information (Hoq, 2014 & Salim, 2003).

Aims
The aim of this paper is to identify skills librarians learnt at work and not during their studies at the Universities, what skills if any they lack when assisting users and how they how they help users who are experiencing information overload.


Required skills for LIS professionals in today’s world
Due to rapid advancements in the LIS discipline, Sridhar (2000) as cited in Singh and Pinki (2009) library professionals must have technical, IT, and managerial skills as the world keeps changing, hence acquiring skills for the new information environment is the demand of the time.  Information Technology (IT) skills includes networking skills, library automation, online search engines, online databases, desktop publishing, digitization.   
Skills needed for working as digital information professional also require knowledge of web publishing, database development and management systems, web design skills and information literacy (Nonthacumjane, 2011). Online searching skills, database development and management, web page design, knowledge of CSS, XML, HTML, effective search on WWW, digitization, web publishing are all essentials to the 21st century librarians (Khan & Bhatti, 2015). Farkas (2008) opined that apart from database searching, librarians need to be able to search and locate quality online resources.  Librarians cannot provide services especially reference services without basic internet and research skills.  IT skills include troubleshooting skills to enable librarians fix problems related to troubleshooting as this is a librarian’s responsibility to fix these problems. 
Other skills apart from IT skills include managerial, subject knowledge, teamwork, project management, and knowledge of international standard, commitment to the profession, flexibility and knowledge of dealing with a range of users (Nonthacumjane, 2011).  To work in a digital environment, information professionals are required to have knowledge of metadata standards, makeup language such as HTML, SGML, XML, experience in cataloguing electronic publications and web design (Nonthacumjane, 2011).
IT is an important course which should be included in the LIS curriculum (Nonthacumjane, 2011).  LIS professionals are required to obtain basic knowledge of ICT applications in order for them to know how to integrate ICT technologies in offering different library services (Khan & Bhatti, 2015).    Due to the advent of information and communication technologies, new hybrid skills and competencies are required (Singh & Pinki, 2009).  Many libraries offer both hard-copies as well as digital information collections; these are called “hybrid” libraries.  Hybrid libraries offers among other services online access catalogues, online catalogues or digital repository of dissertations, thesis and other e-resources (Nieuwenhuysen, n.d.).
In today’s world, library professionals serve many roles such as being a helpful facilitator in searching and evaluating required information (Nonthacumjane, 2011). Library professionals need to possess knowledge and experience of electronic information searching, retrieving and delivery such as e-sources and e-journals (Hyett, 2000). In a digital environment, LIS professionals should act as facilitators or mentors to help the users to find information needed and evaluate it. For this reason, the new information era librarians need to know how to do  manage content, analyse, retrieve, share and preserve digital information (Nonthacumjane, 2011; (Hashim & Mokhtar, 2012).  Farkas (2008), is of the view that searching skills are very crucial to LIS profession hence no library student should be allowed to graduate without basic internet and search skills.
Marketing skills are still essential to the librarianship profession in today’s world.  Universities should teach students how to sell library services and new ideas to different stakeholders (Farkas, 2008).  Training/teaching skills plays a major role in LIS profession.  Librarians should possess training/teaching skills, writing skills, public communication skills and presentation skills (Hyett, 2000; Nonthacumjane, 2011). Furthermore, librarians should exhibit leadership skills (Nonthacumjane, 2011; Singh & Pinki, 2009). Leadership skills include critical thinking, risk taking and creativity regardless of the position within the management structure (Singh & Pinki, 2009).

Information overload
Most of the resources now exist in electronic formats. This new development has resulted in information overload.  The speedy production of information in different information sources has contributed to information overload (Hoq, (2014). Ruff (2002) said that the definition of information overload includes the negative impact on performance due to too much information exposure. Information literacy plays a very crucial role in efficiently dealing with information overload. According to American Library Association (2000), acquiring information literacy skills enable a person to be able to access and evaluate relevant information sources critically.
A user, who is knowledgeable about Internet searching, is likely to retrieve relevant information compared to the one who is not.  ICT is an essential tool for dealing with information overload (Hog, 2014; Salim, 2003).
 Catalogues, indexes and bibliographies can sensibly be used to help an information seeker to promptly locate and retrieve needed information. Libraries and information providers have to strengthen library orientation to users to deal with the issue of information overload.  Furthermore,

Research methodology
The paper made use of qualitative and quantitative research design methodology to collect and analyse data.    The target population of this was qualified and employed librarians in Namibia. 42 participants took part in this exercise. A purposive sample was used which falls under nonprobability sampling. A purposive sampling technique is also referred to as nonprobability sampling or purposive sampling or qualitative sampling.  Purposive sampling involves selecting certain units or cases based on a specific purpose rather than randomly (Teddlie & Yu, 2007). Purposive sampling was based on the research goals. Data was collected using questionnaires which had both closed and open ended questions.  Participants were asked not to put their names or any type of identification on the questionnaire as part of research ethics.  They were also assured that their information will be treated confidentially.

Paper’s findings
Demographic information
Gender of participants
Majority (37) of the participants indicated they were female compared to only 5 who indicated they were male. This in a way reflect that majority of the people in the library field are women.
Gender

Female
37
Male
5
Table 1: participants’ users


Qualifications
Only one (1) participant out of 42 indicated has a master’s degree and this shows that librarianship is a field that has not been explored that much in Namibia.
Qualification
No. of Participants
Masters
1
Degree
31
Diploma
10
Table 2: participants’ qualifications

Positions hold by LIS professionals
Majority (13) of the participants indicated they were librarians.
Chief Librarian
Chief Health Programmer
Senior Librarian
Librarian
Assistant Librarian
Acting Assistant Librarian
Senior Library Assistant
Library Assistant
2
1
6
13
10
1
1
8
Table3: Participants’ positions

Years of experience in Libraries and Information Centres

Majority (8) of the participants indicated they had only one (1) year of experience and only one (1) had twenty-eight (28) years of experience. This shows that majority of the librarians are new into the profession.

Year of working experience
No. of years
No. of participants
less than a year
4
1year
8
2years
4
3years
7
4years
7
5years
7
7years
1
9years
1
10years
1
11years
1
28years
1
Table 4: Participants years of experience

Resources mostly required by users
Majority (29%) of the participants indicated that resources mostly required by users are books.
Resources
Percentage
Books
29%
Internet
27%
Electronic database
11%
Thesis/research paper/reports
10%
Government publication
7%
Serials
7%
DVDs/Video tapes/ microfilms
5%
Statistics/annual reports
3%
Conference paper
1%
Table 5: Resources mostly required

Day-to-day tasks of LIS professionals
Participants were asked to identify their day-to-day tasks in their respective working environments.  Tasks performed by LIS professionals are as follows:
·         Circulation duties
·         Information literacy
·         Library administration work
·         Marketing and advertising
·         Reference services
·         Management functions
·         Cataloguing and classification
·         Submission and report writings
·         Information retrieval
·         ICT skills Teaching/Training
·         Acquisition
·         Shelving
·         User education and user satisfaction studies
·         Facilitate reading programs
·         Newspaper clipping
·         Processing Library Materials
·         Statistic compilation

Practical skills learnt at workplace
Participants were asked to indicate the practical skills they have learnt at their working places. These are skills they have not learnt at the university during their training.  Participants revealed that they have learnt the following practical skills at their work places:
·         Management functions
·         Developing annual plan
·         Server maintenance
·         Handling different user groups
·         Submission and report writing
·         Shelving
·         Customer services
·         Conflict management
·         Presentation skills
·         Leadership skills
·         Stocktaking
·         Interpersonal skills
·         Library integrated system usage
·         Library orientation
·         Digitizing
·         E-resources searching skills
·         Databases
·         Acquisition
·         Online cataloguing and classification
·         Processing library materials
·         Circulation of library materials
·         Preservation of books

Do librarians easily find information users are looking for?
Majority (26) of the participants indicated ‘Yes’ to the question whether they find the information users are looking for?
Yes
Sometimes
No
26
13
3
Table 6: Finding information

Lack of skills among LIS professionals
One of the objectives was to establish what skills librarians are lacking. Out of 42 participants, only 12 participants indicated the skills they lack and the skills are as follows:
·         Information retrieval and searching skills (8)
·         Language barriers (2)
·         Information literacy (1)
·         Customer service (1)



How do library professionals help users experiencing information overload?
In response to the question of how librarians help users who are experiencing information overload, the participants said the following:
·         Focus and pay attention to keywords of the question.
·         Encourage users to focus on what is related to his task, ignoring the irrelevant information,
·         Encourage use of strategic searching and give users tips on how to improve their searching skills e.g. the use of Boolean operators.
·         Usage of table of content, index and abstract to get specific information required fast.
·         Provide advice and guidelines on searching the internet effectively where by one have to demonstrate how to conduct such a search. Make sure you literate the user on different sources of information and online platform where such sources are available.
·         Help users to filter the information by selecting relevant information to the topic.
·         Help users by formulating and narrowing their research questions.
·         Engage in a reference interview with the user.
·         Recommend journal articles since they are peer reviewed and the information is current as compared to other library materials.
·         Teach users how to evaluate different information sources such as author’s credibility and currency of the source
·         Teach and encourage users to get information from databases instead of the general internet.
·         Tell users to draw a mind map of the important points about a certain topic.
·         Teaching library users on information skills
Majority of participants emphasised on helping users by selecting the relevant information, teaching information literacy, by making sure that the user understand the topic in question, use of keywords and through information filtering.




Library professional training
Majority of the participants responded ‘satisfying’ to best describe their training at the University. However, 17 were neutral.  Figure 3 below represent the responses.

Satisfying
Neutral
Dissatisfying
23
17
2
Table 7: Training

Skills improvement
The paper intended to find out if participants had an opportunity to go back to the University, which skills they would want to improve on so that they can be effective in their jobs as librarians.  Participants revealed that they would want to improve the following skills:
·         Library management system
·         Databases
·         Writing skills
·         Online cataloguing and classification
·         Article publishing
·         Reference materials usage
·         Customer care
·         Information Technology (IT) skills
·         Information literacy skills
·         Research and Information retrieval skills
·         Teaching/training skills
·         Leadership skills
·         Technical skills such as networking and troubleshooting
·         Marketing skills
·         Digitization
·         Budgeting and acquisition
·         Web design
·         Desktop publishing

General comments
Participants were asked to give general comments on the preparedness of library professionals for new information environment.  The following comments were made:
·         “Library Science students should be provided with longer Internship”.
·         There is need for librarians to share best practises (information and knowledge).
·         Librarians need to be trained on customer care services.
·         Workshops or seminars on internet (the server), SPSS, customer care, databases relating to libraries, ordering library, finance and community projects librarians can run effectively and how to do it.
·         “Teaching/training skills must be incorporated in Library and Information Science”.
·         Universities must incorporate more Information Technology related subjects in the curriculum.
·         “Librarians are not always prepared to deal with any kind of library hence the degree programme is too general, most of the skills and approaches are often adapted on the job.”
·         “Universities must do more practical instead of more theory.”
·         Centralising functions such as cataloguing and classification provide fewer opportunities for graduates to gain experience.
·         “Teach library students how to set up new libraries”.
·         Universities must add specialities so that individuals can specialise in a specific library job.

Discussion of findings
Practical at workplace and not university
Librarians have indicated that they have acquired several skills at their workplaces which they had not learnt during their trainings at universities.  Skills such as report writing, customer care, management, library management systems, developing, accessing, and maintaining library databases, conflict management, e-resources searching, digitisation, sever maintenance, managing library websites, stocktaking and computerised cataloguing and classification. 
Working in different types of libraries requires one to have skills to deal and handle different types of users groups.  At Universities, librarians are not necessarily trained in-depth on how to deal with specific users.  For librarians to be fully equipped, instead of studying librarianship in general, subjects dealing with area of specialisation must be introduced for instance where by librarians can specialised in children, community, school libraries etc.  Comments from the respondents showed that librarians are not always prepared to deal with any kind of library as the degree programme offered is too general, thus most of skills and approaches are usually gained at workplace.  This is evident from the list of skills that participants indicated that they have learnt and acquired at their work places and not at universities during their training.
 
Lack of skills among LIS professionals
Even though librarians say they are trained on how to retrieve information in universities and have acquired information retrieval skills from their workplace, this paper have revealed that most librarians in Namibia lack information retrieval and searching skills. According to Shrestha (2008) information retrieval is the process of finding documents or information contained in documents in a library collection or other collection, selectively recalling recorded information.  This is worrisome because information retrieval and searching is day-to-day task of a librarian.  Additionally, Information retrieval is a required skill in the new era.  These findings are opposite to Hashim & Mokhtar (2012) opinions when they stated that in the new era librarians and professionals should be able to manage the digital information systems as this encompass the overall competencies (knowledge, know-how, skills and attitudes) necessary to create, store, analyse, retrieve and disseminate digital information such as text, image and sounds in digital libraries or any other type of information centre. 
According to Nonthacumjane (2011) in today’s world, library professionals serve many roles such as being a helpful facilitator in searching and evaluating required information. Library professionals need to possess knowledge and experience of electronic information searching, retrieving and delivery information such as e-sources and e-journals (Hyett, 2000).  According to this paper’s findings, this is not the situation in Namibia as Librarians are facing challenges when it comes to retrieving e-resources and especially accessing academic articles.  In most cases librarians do not find the right and exact information required by users. 
Furthermore, librarians encounter difficulties when retrieving information from electronic databases.  Most of the resources now exist in electronic formats.  Besides, the industry is requiring librarians to be familiar with new ways of searching electronic information sources and the ability to evaluate the validity and authenticity of the information sources.  Nonthacumjane, (2011) notes that online search engines, online search databases search are skills required for librarians, hence acquiring these skills for the new environment is the demand of the time.
Furthermore, due to the advent of information and communication technologies, new hybrid skills and competencies are required (Singh & Pinki, 2009).  Lack of search and information retrieval skills are obstacles to the provision of library services.  Farkas (2008) says that librarians cannot provide services especially reference services without basic internet and research skills.  Some librarians are slow to respond to users’ requests and provide them with information they need.  In this era, time management is a skill required. “I would say I am too slow to respond to their requests at times and I don’t always get the right information needed”. According to Singh & Pinki (2009) time management is a managerial skill which is necessary for library professionals as this skill fulfil the fourth law of Ranganathan (save the time of the user).
Therefore librarians have to be adequately trained in information technology to excel in the new environment of librarianship.  However, the paper discovered that most LIS professionals are not well prepared for the working environment particularly in the new era environment. Thus universities should equip students with adequate research and information retrieval skills.  The paper revealed that some librarians would like to improve on their research and information retrieval skills if given any opportunity.
For library professionals to be effective in their working environments there is a need to improve skills in how to develop, access and maintain databases.  Moreover, it is essential to improve cataloguing and classification skills particularly on-line cataloguing and classification.   Moreover, universities should focus on providing students with longer internship and concentrate on more practical rather than theory.
As for language barriers, is not necessary a lack of skill but rather a challenge which is an obstacle for librarians to be effective and efficient in services provision.  Another essential skill lacking among Namibian LIS professionals is information literacy.
 Information literacy is the ability to taper the required knowledge from the pool of information available from different resources (Shrestha, 2008).  Naik and Padmini (2014) defined information literacy as a set of skills needed to find, retrieve, analyse and use information.  To survive in the information age, one needs information literacy skills (Naik & Padmini, 2014).  This paper finding tells us that some Namibian library professions are having challenges surviving in the information age as they lack information literacy skills.
Libraries should organise information literacy training programme for their users to help users navigate their information.  This training should include how to formulate search strategies use various e-resources and databases (Naik & Padmini, 2014).  Based on this paper’s findings, how can library professionals provide information literacy considering they lack the skill?  Other skills lacking among LIS professionals are customer service skills.  How helpful staff are to users have a big impact on user’s experience.  How you treat and handle users determine whether they are likely to return or not (Marcus, 2011).  Many staff members in public libraries are trained in providing advice and guidance in customer service (Marcus, 2011).  This statement does not correspond with this paper’s findings as librarians are lacking customer service skills.
It has been observed that out of 42 participants, only one (1) has a masters’ degree in LIS, this could’ve contributed to lack of these skills among librarians as the librarianship has not been explored that much in Namibia.   The paper also revealed that most of library professionals are still new to the profession, majority (8) of them have only one year of working experience in the profession.

Information overload
The paper aimed to find out how library professionals help users experiencing information overload. The paper discovered that in order to assist users undergoing information overload, Librarians are involved in information literacy training to well-educate library users.  Information literacy is provided with the aim of ensuring library users are independent to deal with information overload. The findings confirm the opinions of (Hoq, 2014; Salim, 2003) who noted that librarians have a responsibility to educate the users on judicious use of information.  The findings also agree with (American Library Association, 2000) it is very important to educate end-users in information processing techniques.
 To overcome information overload, librarians assist users to filter their information.  When searching for information online, users are advised to use Boolean operators which aid to filter information.  According to Salim (2003) information seekers hardly have time and expertise to find the information that best serve their needs. Therefore, it is important to develop filtering systems.  The past ideas include a quality information filtering systems which reduces the quantity of journal literature on a specific subject to a few relevant and easy accessible items.

Recommendations
·         More courses such as customer care, information literacy, information technology and web designing should be added to library and information science curriculum to meet the requirements of the new librarianship environment.
·         Courses in information search and retrieval should be taught in-depth, to eliminate lack of these skills.
·         Internship duration should be longer to allow LIS students to gain practical skills.
·         Training institutions and LIS professionals in practice should meet to discuss how best LIS students can be prepared for the new working environment. 

Conclusion
Despite the fact that a large number of participants indicated ‘satisfying’ in response to the question of describing their training, the overall result of the paper has revealed that most of  librarians in Namibia are not sufficiently prepared for the new information working environment. They lack information retrieval skills which are a librarian’s daily task and also a skill required in today’s information working environment. In addition, they lack information literacy and customer service skills. Lack of these skills is due to inadequate exposure to the field and inadequate working experience.  Thus there is a need to improve on these skills in order for LIS professionals in Namibia to be effective in their new working environment


References
American Library Association. (2000). Information Literacy Competency Standards for
Edonkumoh, V., Nwachukwu, V.N. and Emmanuel, A. (2015).Graduate Students Internship
 Experience and Its Impact on Practical Skills Development in LIS Education: A Survey. Library Philosophy and Practice 11(24).  Retrieved from http://digitalcommons.unl.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=3644&context=libphilprac
Farkas, M. (2006). Skills for the 21st century librarian. Retrieved from
Hashim, L. B. and Mokhtar, W. N. H. (2012). Preparing New Era Librarians and Information
Professionals: Trends and Issues. International Journal of Humanities and Social Science 2(7). Retrieved from http://www.ijhssnet.com/journals/Vol_2_No_7_April_2012/16.pdf
Hoq, K. M. G. (2014). Information overload: causes, consequences and remedies: A study.
 Philosophy and Progress LV-LVI (1-2).  Retrieved from http://dx.doi.org/10.3329/pp.v55i1-2.26390
Hyett, D. (2000). New roles and skills for librarians. Retrieved from
Khan, S. A. and Bhatti, R. (2015). Towards digital libraries: Investigating digital skills for
Larson, P. D. and Kulchitsky, J. D. (2007). Information Overload: Too Much of a Good
Marcus (2011). Customer Service and Relationship Management. Retrieved from
Nagarajan, S. and Edwards, J. (2015). The Role of Universities, Employers, Graduates and
Professional Associations in the Development of Professional Skills of New Graduates. Journal of Perspectives in Applied Academic Practice 3(2). Retrieved from http://jpaap.napier.ac.uk/index.php/JPAAP/article/view/137/html
Naik, M. M. and Padmini (2014). Importance of information literacy. International Journal of
Digital Library Services, 4(3). Retrieved from http://www.ijodls.in/uploads/3/6/0/3/3603729/9434.pdf
Nieuwenhuysen, P. (n.d.). Information retrieval systems in scientific and technological
 libraries: from monolith to puzzle and beyond. Retrieved from http://www.vub.ac.be/BIBLIO/nieuwenhuysen/presentations/2006-05-iatul-porto/iatul_v16_fps_7_4.pdf
Nonthacumjane, P. (2011). Key skills and competencies of a new generation of LIS
Professionals. IFLA journals 37(4) pp 280-288. DOI: 10.1177/0340035211430475
Rowland, F. (1998, April). The Librarian's Role in the Electronic Information Environment.
 Paper presented at the ICSU Press Workshop., Keble College, Oxford. Retrieved from http://www.bodley.ox.ac.uk/icsu/rowlandppr.htm
Ruff, J. (2002). Information Overload: Causes, Symptoms and Solutions. Retrieved from
Salim, M. (2003). Information overload and its implication for a corporate library: As
 perceived by eight researchers at AstraZeneca. Retrieved from http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.99.8681&rep=rep1&type=pdf
Shrestha, S. (2008). Study on need and importance of information literacy in Nepal: special
emphasis to students of MLISC, tu, central department of library and information science and professionals of kathmandu valley. Retrieved from http://eprints.rclis.org/22582/1/SarojaShrestha.pdf
 Singh, S. P. and Pinki (2009). New Skills for LIS Professionals in Technology-Intensive
Teddlie, C. and Yu, S. (2007). Mixed methods sampling: A typology with examples.